Skip to content
VRM Atlas
Get quotes

Market report · October 2026Score 6.8 · #14 of 89

St. Augustine & Amelia Island holiday rental market report, October 2026

26 vacation rental managers in St. Augustine & Amelia Island, United States, 3,400 active holiday rentals, average $345 a night, 47% occupancy. Seasonality, typical rates and who manages the homes.

All 26 managers in St. Augustine & Amelia Island

Atlas Market Score 6.8#14 of 89 markets

All markets ranked
  1. 6.8Demand47% · Seasonal
  2. 7.3Yield$163 per available night
  3. –GrowthNo data yet
  4. 6.2Return on investment10.9% gross yield · $4,200/m²
  5. 6.1Ease of entryForeigners can own · short lets restricted · 30% tax on rental income
  6. –Climate and accessNo data yet

Each part scores 0–10 among the markets with data; the score is their weighted average. Missing parts are left out, never guessed.

Key figures

Managers on Atlas
26
Active holiday rentals
3,400
Average nightly rate
$345
Average occupancy
47%
Homes these managers run
1,230+
Typical portfolio
10 homes
Busiest month
March
Self-managed homes
67%

What stands out in St. Augustine & Amelia Island

  • March is the busiest month at 61% occupancy; January is the quietest at 37%. Seasonal market.
  • Half of homes sit between $195 and $395 a night. Top quarter: above $395 · Top 10%: above $615.
  • 33% of listings are professionally managed; 67% are run by their owners.
  • 26 managers here publish their portfolio size. The typical one runs 10 homes, and 7 run 25 or more.
  • None of the 26 managers in St. Augustine & Amelia Island has claimed a profile yet: the first to do so stands out to every owner searching here.

The market

Seasonality in St. Augustine & Amelia IslandSeasonal

Peak: March (61%, $370) · Quietest: January (37%, $325)

  1. Oct: 40%
  2. Nov: 40%
  3. Dec: 47%
  4. Jan: 37%
  5. Feb: 51%
  6. Mar: 61%
  7. Apr: 51%
  8. May: 47%
  9. Jun: 58%
  10. Jul: 53%
  11. Aug: 41%
  12. Sep: 39%

Typical rates, occupancy by area and how many homes are professionally managed are on the St. Augustine & Amelia Island page with a free account.

Market data, Oct 2026. Figures are aggregates for the area, never a single home or host.

Who manages the homes

26 vacation rental managers listed in St. Augustine & Amelia Island: 0 claimed, 0 verified.

2–4 homes7
5–24 homes12
25+ homes7

Managers that publish their portfolio size.

  1. Coastal Realty FL300 homes
  2. Slvrst140 homes
  3. Euphoria Vacation Homes73 homes
  4. Barefoot Amelia23 homes
  5. Opulent Property23 homes
  6. Guest Cottage18 homes
  7. Serene Retreats10 homes
  8. The Good Host10 homes
  9. Casa De Hernandez6 homes
  10. Mag Accommodations6 homes
  11. A Nora Spaces308 homes
  12. Colony Reef63 homes

Compare every manager in St. Augustine & Amelia Island · ranking is by profile evidence; paying never changes the order.

Manage homes in St. Augustine & Amelia Island?

Owners use this report and the St. Augustine & Amelia Island directory to choose a manager. Claim your free profile to add your logo, portfolio, fees and reviews. Featured here? Add a link from your website:

<a href="https://vrmatlas.com/reports/st-augustine" title="St. Augustine & Amelia Island vacation rental managers on VRM Atlas">Featured in the VRM Atlas St. Augustine & Amelia Island market report</a>
Claim your profile

VRM Atlas maps vacation rental managers worldwide. Manager figures come from Atlas profiles and public information; market figures are aggregates from licensed data. Report URL: https://vrmatlas.com/reports/st-augustine